Thinking About Switching Billers?
“I don’t know if our billing company is doing a bad job. I just know collections feel soft and I can’t get a straight answer.” If that’s you, not knowing is the answer. You can’t trust a billing relationship you can’t see into.
Updated October 25, 2026
The Signs Owners Usually Ignore Too Long
Most owners tolerate a failing biller for a year or more because switching feels riskier. In our experience, these signs mean the relationship has already failed and you’re still paying for it.
No Denial Visibility
You can’t get a denial rate, category breakdown or list of claims on appeal. A biller who can’t produce denial data on request usually isn’t working denials systematically. The labor intensive part of medical billing gets dropped.
A/R Aging Silently
Your 90-plus-day bucket grows month over month and nobody flags it. Old A/R is where soft performance hides: claims denied and never reworked, or never followed up, sitting until they become write-offs.
No Real Reporting
You get a monthly collections total, maybe, but no charges vs collections trend, payer level breakdown, clean claim rate or net collection rate. A number without context is reassurance, not reporting. You shouldn’t have to ask twice for your own data.
A Generalist Biller Doing Expert Work
Behavioral health billing has its own terrain: psychotherapy add-on codes, time based E/M, carve-out payers, auth gated interventional services, incident-to rules, telehealth nuances. A biller who mostly does primary care or ortho tends to under-code, mis-bill or write off what they don’t recognize.
How To Plan The Billing Transition
Practices stay in bad billing relationships for fear of the gap, a month or two of chaos where nothing gets collected. A properly run transition is designed to prevent it:
- Overlap, not handoff. The outgoing biller typically works existing A/R for an agreed run-out period (check your contract; most have run-out terms) while the new team takes all new charges from a clean cutover date.
- Baseline audit first. Before cutover, the incoming team documents open A/R by bucket and payer, denial backlog, credentialing status, fee schedules and EDI/ERA enrollments. It’s your to-do list and the before picture for future reporting.
- EDI, ERA, and portal re-enrollment early. Clearinghouse and remit enrollments take lead time and are the most common cause of transition hiccups. Start them the day you decide, not the day the old contract ends.
- Weekly reporting from week one. The fastest way to check a transition is to see charges out, payments in and denials worked every week from the start. If a new biller doesn’t offer that, you’re trading one black box for another.
Done this way, practices typically see continuity in deposits through the transition, and the first ninety days usually surface recoverable money the old biller left in aged A/R.
Questions To Ask Any Prospective Biller
Whether you talk to us or anyone else, these questions separate real billing operations from claim submission shops:
- “What percentage of your clients are behavioral health?” You want an expert, or at least a dedicated behavioral health team, not a generalist learning your specialty on your revenue.
- “Show me a sample of the reporting I’ll receive.” It should include denial rate and categories, A/R by aging bucket and payer, net collection rate and clean claim rate, on a schedule, without asking.
- “How do you work denials, and how fast?” Listen for a defined workflow with turnaround targets and appeal deadline tracking, not “we rework them as they come in.”
- “Who owns credentialing status, and how does billing know about it?” Credentialing denials live in the gap between the credentialing spreadsheet and the billing team. A good biller closes it; see how we handle it in revenue cycle management.
- “What does my exit look like?” A confident biller explains run-out terms, data ownership and transition support plainly. Evasiveness about leaving tells you how it will end.
Where We Fit
We built our mental health billing around the failure points above: deep behavioral health focus, denials worked as part of the billing and owner reports by default. As Ongoing Billing, it’s priced by practice size, from 7% of collections with a $300 monthly minimum for a solo provider down to 4.5% at 26 to 50 providers, with no setup fee (see medical billing prices by practice size).
Old biller left aged A/R behind? Billing Cleanup And A/R Recovery works claims older than 90 days for 20% of what we collect, and nothing on claims we don’t.
If the review shows your current biller is doing the job, we’ll tell you. Some practices think they have a biller problem when it’s really a front end eligibility or credentialing sync problem. The fix differs, and a wrong diagnosis wastes a year.
Common Questions
Will Switching Billers Disrupt Our Cash Flow?
Not if it’s managed. The outgoing biller works existing A/R through a run-out period while the new team takes all new charges from a clean cutover date, and EDI/ERA re-enrollments start early. Practices typically see deposit continuity through the switch.
How Long Does A Billing Transition Take?
Plan on 30 to 60 days from decision to full cutover, driven mostly by clearinghouse and remit re-enrollment lead times and your contract’s notice terms. The baseline audit and reporting setup run in parallel, so the new operation is measurable from day one.
What Happens To Our Old Unpaid Claims?
Run-out terms in your contract usually decide who works them. When the old biller’s run-out effort is weak, which is common, the incoming team can take over aged A/R after cutover and triage it by appeal and filing deadlines to recover what’s still collectible.
How Do I Know If The Problem Is Really My Biller?
Repeated eligibility and auth denials usually point at front end workflow; provider not eligible denials point at credentialing; slow follow-up, aging A/R and missing reports point at the biller. A baseline audit sorts it out before you change anything.
Do You Require Long-Term Contracts?
We work on terms that let performance keep the relationship, and we put reporting in your hands from week one. That reporting covers denial rate and categories, A/R by aging bucket and payer, and net collection rate.
About The Author
Ryan Berg is the founder of AdvanceAPractice. He has run the business side of medical, dental and behavioral health practices for more than 16 years, including claims work at OHSU and operations at a multi provider psychiatry practice.